Discussion: Pretty Cover, Pretty Book?

Join the open discussion about whether how book covers look affects whether it is likely to become popular, or whether it doesn’t matter at all. We all remember the covers of our favorite books, but are they our favorites because of the cover, or do we remember them because they’re our favorites?


I recently decided to buy a used copy of To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, not because I wanted to read the book (I already have) and not because I genuinely needed the copy, but because the cover was so pretty I couldn’t resist!  Because of that, it made me start thinking about the value of covers, and how much they influence who reads the book, and how popular it becomes.

I know about the old saying, “Don’t judge a book by it’s cover” but we all know that that’s virtually impossible. When you’re in the library, or a used bookstore, your eyes scan for book covers (or more accurately, sides) that pop out Andy intrigue you. Then, for me, I read the back and make a final decision. I can’t even count how many incredible books I’ve picked out this way. So that proves that at least sometimes, it works.

But then I think of all of the books that i might be missing out on because their covers didn’t make me want to pick them up in the store. There could be an AMAZING author out there who goes undiscovered not because of bad marketing technique, but because people don’t like the cover that they see in advertisements or on the shelf.  Do you think that this occurs? In my opinion, a large reason that I never pick up adult contemporary romance novels is that the covers always somehow look cheesy, and that’s a huge turn off. But, on the other hand, 50 Shades of Grey by E.L.James has a more intriguing cover, and, although I didn’t read it myself, it got a huge amount of interest and made me want to read it (the only reason I didn’t is that my mom cleverly kept it off her shelf). So, using that as an example, it does seem like the covers make a difference. Or else James’ story was so freaking incredible that it got enough attention regardless of the cover. Still though, I can’t imagine the entire world reading a book with one of those cliche romance covers.  It’s this indecision that forced me to write this post. I just need somebody to make a logical argument that I can agree with.

I think, if the cover does determine the popularity of a novel, this becomes a huge problem for Indie authors who don’t have the funding to hire people to make it for them. In this case, they’re already at a disadvantage to print huge copies, and they’re unknown, but even the books they get on the shelf are less likely to be chosen because, to be honest, if you are going to buy a book you want it to be an attractive addition to your shelf. Do you think there’s anything we can do to change this?

The opposite problem is also just as big.  When you buy a book because it sounds half decent and it has a pretty cover, but it sucks, that’s a huge letdown.  You go in having such high expectations, and then they are just crushed by the weight of the actual words.  I have found this to be a huge problem lately, with authors paying more attention to their artwork than their actual work.  Maybe that’s just me, I don’t know.

I also believe that Kindle and other Ereaders are helping this to become less of a problem, as you don’t really care about what the black and white picture that you only see once, if that, looks like.  When you carry around your Kindle, you don’t see the book cover, so it is essentially irrelevant.

I know I just ranted for a while on a post with contradictory viewpoints and labeled it a discussion, but that is because I really want to hear what you guys have to say about this topic.  Reply, argue (nicely), and help convince me as to the value, or lack thereof, of book covers.  Please, because this state of confusion is slowly killing me.

Self Promotions:

Twitter: @isobel_moon

Goodreads: Isobel Moon

My favorite post when I wrote this


Author: Joce

I read and I write about it. If I'm not online or with my nose in a book, I can probably be found at the basketball court.

2 thoughts on “Discussion: Pretty Cover, Pretty Book?”

  1. I think that book covers will always and forever be a very large factor in whether we pick up a book or not. Even on Kindle, if you’re scrolling through books to download, the first thing you see is it’s digital cover image. So while the cover loses its materialistic value through Kindle, (a.k.a no one’s buying it solely because it looks pretty) the initial incentive to buy it still leans heavily on the book cover. I definitely agree that people with bad marketing teams, or indie authors with no marketing team are at a disadvantage, because they really could’ve produced a gorgeous book, but plenty of people will turn it down simply because of the cover. In my opinion, pretty cover does NOT necessarily mean pretty book. Great post!!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s