By Barbara Copperthwaite
Rating: 🙂 🙂 🙂
Goodreads Rating: 4.05
Genre: Psychological Thriller
Publication Date: May 12th 2017
Format Read: Phone Ebook via Netgalley
Goodreads Summary: A mother desperate for the truth. A daughter hiding a terrible secret.
Melanie Oak appeared to have the perfect life. Married to her childhood sweetheart, Jacob, the couple live with their beautiful, loving, teenage daughter, Beth, in a pretty village.
Nothing can shake her happiness – until the day that Beth goes missing and is discovered beaten almost to the point of death, her broken body lying in a freezing creek on the marshes near their home.
Consumed with grief, Melanie is determined to find her daughter’s attacker. Someone in the village must have seen something. Why won’t they talk?
As Melanie tries to piece together what happened to Beth, she discovers that her innocent teenager has been harbouring some dark secrets of her own. The truth may lie closer to home and put Melanie’s life in terrible danger…
A completely gripping psychological thriller with a twist you won’t see coming.
It took all of my strength to keep reading this book. I got bored just as short way through, thrown off by the 2nd person POV and the fact that the plot was not very interesting, but I kept reading, something which I’m fairly glad of. The last 20% of the book was incredible, and bumped my rating up a star. The first 80%, however, didn’t hold my interest at all.
The basic concept is that a young teenager, Beth, goes missing, and the book is told from the perspective of the mother telling the story of her DIY detective work to her daughter. There were also perspectives from Beth (from the night she goes missing) and a mysterious individual mixed in.
Bottom line is that nothing in this book got me super attached. The plotline wasn’t intriguing, I hated Melanie (the MC, aka Beth’s mother), her partner in solving crime seemed like the biggest stock character I’ve ever met, and all of the “villagers” had 0 dimension. They were all flat. The only one I liked is the husband, and I felt like even he did a thing that didn’t seem to fit with the rest of his character ,at all.
Luckily the ending was good. Well, one of the endings. The major storyline that everything was working towards fell flat for me, but in the last 20% Copperthwaite had a side story line that she had been progressing and made it the center stage, and for me THAT was the only intriguing part of the novel.
Beth is the girl who goes missing. You really only hear about her from her mother’s POV, and occasionally from her own, but she’s a dynamic, interesting girl, and I liked her and wished the best for her. That’s probably the only reason I didn’t DNF. I HAD to know what happened to Beth.
Melanie, the MC, is Beth’s mother, but she just MAKES ME SO MAD I CAN’T EXPLAIN. She’s not that good of a person, although she thinks she is, and she’s super self absorbed and can’t see the world around her. It was painful, and I found myself looking forward to the short, one page segments that were not from her point of view just so that I didn’t have to listen to the whining drunk anymore.
Glenn, her partner in solving the crime, is a figure from her childhood who she was not exceptionally close with, but happens to waltz into her life and “just want to help”. Mel bought it. So he’s around for the entire novel, and despite this fact, he has ZERO DIMENSION. I don’t understand how I can read a whole book with him at center stage and still not really KNOW him aside from the one central fact (it’s a spoiler so I won’t say). It’s weird.
The husband, Jacob? (I think, we’ll go with it), was my favorite character, but the author made him do something so completely out of character with everything else we saw that he started to feel fake as well.
The plot was very, very slow. This 433 page book could have easily been condensed into 200 pages and you would not have lost any of the red herrings, dramatic moments, etc, because there was so much WASTED SPACE SPENT DOING NOTHING.
Of course, that changed slightly in the last bit, where there was action, character development, a big reveal, an oh shit moment where you realized what was really going on, and an overall good pace. But that doesn’t happen soon enough.
I know books won’t have action the whole way through, but something needs to be happening, or at least characters being developed, for it to be interesting.
And the whole “why won’t the village talk” thing that propelled the entire plot felt fake and strange to me, their motivation not really that good.
- The Ending
- Laughing at MC’s stupidity and lack of awareness for the world around her
- Melanie, her stupidity, and her lack of awareness for the world around her
- Slow Plot
- Poor writing style– there was nothing remotely extraordinary about her writing, the whole thing was very simple and told straightforwardly.
- OBVIOUS display of clues– there was never any clue that I looked back on later and was like, ooooh I missed that… It was all shoved aggressively in your face.
None. There’s one character who may or may not be gay but that’s all. And he’s in the story for like 5 minutes and accused of hurting Beth.
SPOILERS ABOUND, ALTHOUGH NONE ARE THAT BIG.
- A child is brutalized and left to die
- Child is raped
- Drinking problem to deal with other problems
- Drugs abound
This book was a 2 star read all the way through, but the ending was 4 or 5 stars, so I adjusted accordingly with a 3. I wouldn’t recommend this book to anybody, but if you already have it, you might as well read it and see where it goes, it wasn’t so bad as to warrant you not reading it at all.
I’d love to know what other people think of the character development, because for me nobody except Beth felt real.
Buy on Amazon
Add on Goodreads
Disclaimer: I received this eARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Have you read this book? What did you think? Have you read anything else by Barbara Copperthwaite?
Check out my Social Media:
~ Now Venture out and Change the World ~